Sheering Off Another Branch of Government
God help us
Unfortunately, there's little good news on the political front.
A Cliffhanger So Dragged-Out It's Not Exciting Anymore
Foreign Minister Tarasyuk is still there on the brink, after months of shoving by the Party of Regions. They cut off his budget. Now it's back. Everybody's waiting on the Constitutional Court, which, I hope, will mean a more high-profile position for the court and some sort of arbitration to the endless squabbling of Ukrainian politicians.
It's all part of the uncertainty about power that's existed at least since the March elections. PACE recently said, among other things, that it "reduces to zero the hope of political consensus in making further decisions which will speed up the adoption of necessary reforms in Ukraine." (It can say this because it doesn't really have any power, and therefore can dispense with diplomacy in favor of straight talk. Refreshing.)
Tymoshenko And Yanukovych Star In Naked Ambition
Tarasyuk is probably losing ground, though, as Yushchenko loses it. On Jan 12, Tymoshenko joined with Yanu and crew to help strip Yushchenko of even more of his powers as President. Foreign Notes speculates that the move is calculated to try and push Yushchenko further into a corner where calling new elections is his only option. In essence, she voted to strip power from Yushchenko and vest it in Yanukovych. Both Zerkalo Nedeli and EDM believe that it was more a negotiated settlement, in which Yanukovych got his power, and she got her law protecting the opposition and law requiring local officials to dance with the ones who brung them (in other words, remain with the parties they got their positions through).
Even if the Constitutional Court breaks its long silence to overrule this (as it has every reason to do since it's a legal mess), the effort shows complete disregard of democratic institutions by both BYT and PoR. Should the majority in Parliament manage to enforce this travesty, they will have basically sawed off one of the branches of power. Forget about Tymoshenko trying for President in 2009: who'd want that figurehead position? Yanukovych recently said in Davos that "Neither the government nor the prime minister ever aspires to replace the president," which would certainly be true: why replace him when you can simply ignore him and rule alone?
[update: I said "another" branch of government in the title, but forgot to explain why. If you've been counting, this is the second branch of government to be broken off (the judiciary has long been ineffectual). That means it's basically a Parliamentary dictatorship with almost no checks and balances.]
I can hardly get my brain around how foul this is, and how awful for the country it would be. Oh, wait, now I've found the right words: Kuchma was better. Shame and degradation on all those who voted for this law, especially Tymoshenko.
![]()
Kushnaryov killed in a hunting accidentParty of Regions Deputies: Rising and Falling
To put it bluntly, Kushnaryov is dead (image: Reuters). He was on a hunting expedition with fellow PoR deputies and was accidentally fatally wounded by a shot to the stomach. While Foreign Note's entry, cited, mentions that the accident was perpetuated by a supposedly decorated marksman, it's being ruled an accident. Which couldn't be otherwise, because who would investigate the event? Unfortunately, none of the former orange groups look interested, and generally PoR tends to adopt a "devil take the hindmost" stance: if one of theirs falls, it's his own fault.
Not that I was a big fan, or anything (Kushnaryov was from the no-compromise wing of PoR), but it would have been nice to at least have seen an investigation.
Not all PoR deputies' fortunes are so dark. As Foreign Notes has been describing in detail, all the oldest, dirtiest politicians are returning to government, like rats pouring on to a ship that is, remarkably, still afloat despite its deplorable state.
In the midst of all of this, an anniversary few people are probably marking these days: two years of Yu.

Reader Comments (83)
http://blog.taraskuzio.net/2007/01/18/legal-chaos-or-bardak-in-ukraine/
dlw
Absolutely right. A total return of Kuchism.
Depressing which is why I agree with Lutsenko regarding a Spring protest to Kyiv. People cannot be apathetic while the country goes down the tubes.
"The Ukrainian people deserve much better than what they have" stated by Latvian President Vaira Vike-Freiberga at Davos from article " Borshch, Blini And Bodyguards, But No Bill Gates" posted at http://blog.kievukraine.info/
live Internet feed in Ukrainian
http://24news.in.ua/online24tv.php
It is an insane asylum, and the inmates are running the asylum.
Kuchma was not better, he was a thug.
Lutsenko is the only sane, rational one left.
I hope his appeal to the people works.
http://www.kmu.gov.ua/control/en/publish/article;jsessionid=E7B8DA41AF72CEB09CDE8AA6DD4AD877?art_id=64765506&cat_id=2297108
Ouch - major inc. planned in the military sector which if the plan is to go into NATO/EU does not make sense as that would mean a decrease not increase. It also sounds weird because traditionally the military does not ever receive the full amount of funding assigned to it. I wonder if this is the wind up to ousting Hrytsenko?
"Under the Constitution of Ukraine the law is regarded effective after it is published in gazettes "Holos of Ukraine" and "Uriadovyi Kurier".
The majority of the law's provisions fully correspond to the Constitution of Ukraine. However separate articles of the law partially cover issues, which can be settled in the process of Constitutional rather than legislative regulation.
As the President's spokeswoman Iryna Vannykova said, the website of the Verkhovna Rada is not an official media to publish state legal acts."
http://www.kmu.gov.ua/control/en/publish/news_article?art_id=64730120&cat_id=32598
For ex. Anatoliy Matvienko, leader of the nationalist Sobor party, national deputy part of NU
Check out his quote from EDM March 15, 2005 which laid out a YEAR in advance exactly what happened in the March 2006 Parliamentary elections
"Yushchenko's party should target the majority of voters if it wants to be in the majority in the next parliament, but the majority of Ukrainians is anti-NATO and pro-Russian, Matvienko noted. The nationalist electorate, however, is largely pro-NATO and anti-Russian."
http://www.jamestown.org/publications_details.php?volume_id=407&issue_id=3261&article_id=2369409
(The Constitutional ammendments which were voted on in Dec. 2004 which Byut was formerly against in June 2004, which they later voted for and came into effect in Jan. 2006.)
"The 4180 Bill, which people's deputies Stepan Havrsh, Raisa Bogatyriova, Kateryna Vaschuk et al. initiated, collected 276 yeas in its support.
The voting was accompanied by a hullabaloo, which Our Ukraine and BYUT faction members raised in the session hall."
http://www.ukraine-embassy.co.il/english/news/index.php?&rb=28&text=8867&ppage=410
"Bill 3207-1 was passed by the Rada on December 8, 2004 together with Bill 4180 during the "heady" days of the Orange Revolution. Bill 4180 dealt with changes to the Constitution which transferred executive powers from the Presidency to the Cabinet of Ministers and Parliament - i.e. with the issue of separation of powers at the central government level. Bill 3207-1 (the one which the Constitutional Court ruled on yesterday) deals with the
organization of LOCAL governments.
Some may recall that according to the deal struck in Parliament between Kuchma, Yushchenko, et. al. in December, Ukraine's system of government was to change from its current presidential-parliamentary form to a parliamentary-presidential system on January 1 2006"
http://orangeukraine.squarespace.com/long-articles/2005/9/14/court-did-not-endorse-constitutional-changes.html
http://blog.taraskuzio.net/2007/01/31/tarasiuk-goes-what-remains
it matters not to PoR how the dismissal of Tarasiuk looks to the rest of the world, Russia seems to be king...
My hope is in the people of Ukraine...
dlw
The cabinet ministers bill will be publ. with Moroz's signature.
http://5.ua/newsline/179//36543/
President's secretariat calls it an illegal law.
Does the President still believe that this can be solved via a round table?
http://euobserver.com/9/23390?rss_rk=1
According to Chornovil interviewed on day of Tarasyuk's resignation Chalyi is a candidate who would be approved by PoR.
Pres. is to submit his candidate on Feb. 6th.
dlw
"He insisted Russia had helped safeguard newly independent states' sovereignty after the USSR collapsed, but subsidies could not go on for ever.
"We must not subsidise the economies of other countries in large amounts, comparable with their budgets. No one else does that." he said.
He added that new pricing and tariff arrangements with transit countries such as Belarus and Ukraine were aimed "precisely at ensuring the interests of key consumers" in western Europe, for which Moscow should be thanked."
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/f4e756a4-b261-11db-a79f-0000779e2340.html
Foreign Companies Lining Up For Ukrainian Uranium
"However, the country’s leadership is not eager to let them in so soon, opting instead to yield monopoly control over the potentially lucrative business to a yet-to-be-established state behemoth, which would need an estimated $2.4 billion in credit to get on its feet.
As the battle to gain control over the mining of Ukrainian uranium, together with its processing into nuclear fuel, continues, experts say development of the business is key to the nation’s energy security.
Ukraine, which receives about half of its electricity from nuclear power plants, has enough uranium reserves to weed out Russian imports and fill domestic demand for up to 1,000 years.
Just how much uranium Ukraine holds has been kept quiet and subject to state secrecy provisions. "
http://foreignnotes.blogspot.com/2007/02/trust-in-yanukovych.html
http://www.itar-tass.com/eng/level2.html?NewsID=11217506&PageNum=0
This could result in a large number of deaths.
dlw