« Check out the Yushchenko Campaign's Newsletter Site | Main | Don't Miss the Debates on Monday »

The Rear Guard

Recently on Inter Kanal, one of the channels considered to be most biased towards the existing authorities in Ukraine, they ran a new feature that I think gets top points for being an interesting idea. Unfortunately, not even having an antenna on our TV, Lesya and I missed this one. However, our friends were good enough to explain.

For this show, a group of Inter journalists went to L'viv and to Donetsk in cars decorated with campaign symbols from the unpopular candidate for that city.

So one car was in L'viv all decked out in Yanukovych blue and white. It stopped in front of a Yushchenko campaign headquarters and waited. Eventually a number of Yushchenko supporters tried to invite them in or change their minds about their candidate. Things progressed rather calmly.

However, when the journalists went into Donetsk with their Yushchenko colors flying, a number of people started throwing rocks at their car. They were hemmed in in a tunnel and told, in no uncertain terms, to take their colors elsewhere, and left the city in a hurry.

In contrast to this display of feeling, it was the Yushchenko people that could muster many hundreds of thousands of its supporters across long distances to fight to overturn the election fraud. "Active Yanukovych supporters" and "paid" are almost exclusively in the same sentence. If a person speaks up for Yanukovych, well and good, but finding people willing to go to marches and demonstrate on behalf of the man is nearly impossible. If this was just a preference for a candidate, one would expect a much greater showing for Yanukovych.

Why is this?

Eastern Ukrainians are not fighting for anything, they are fighting against, and since they are fighting against, they have no flag around which to rally.

This is not a choice between a "western" and "eastern" route. All people in Ukraine know that the country is struggling and, yes, poor in comparison with Western Europe. All of them know that the country is rank with corruption, and this is the reason that Ukraine's potential is being squandered. West and East want the same standards of living, same prosperity. They want almost the same thing Poland wants, for that matter.

Western Ukraine is reaching for this thing that Poland has. They are reaching for greater speed. They are reaching for western standards of living, they are pushing forward to accelerate the country towards growth. They are uniting around the politician they think will clean up the country. They were animated enough by fraud in the election to shut the whole city down. 

Eastern Ukrainians, however, are fighting like people who think they are the rear guard of a retreating army. They are fighting against a system which they don't believe will increase the prosperity of Ukraine, because they believe the fall of Communism was the start of inexorable decline. They fight because progress will render their own part of the nation less and less important unless they can reform their area in a way few of them can imagine. They fear that Yushchenko is more venal, corrupt, and hideously evil than an excellent example of those traits right in front of them. Miners fight to keep their mines open, to hold onto their livelihood, to hold onto their last last scrap of dignity, while at the same time wishing with their whole souls that their children will never become miners.

The people in the east also want clean government and prosperity, they just don't know where to find it.

Yushchenko supporters can put flowers in the shields of police squads and reach out to Yanukovych supporters without violence in the middle of "their" cities. They can do this because they are fighting for a cause. When Alex (a Yanukovych supporter and frequent commenter here) says they speak from emotion it is true. That emotion is hope.

We are staying at our friend's mother's house. She's 60 years old and registered to vote in a small village outside the city. When she went back home she gathered the same stories you hear in every village. In her village of perhaps 50 houses, 3,000 people voted in the last round of the election. The observers for Yanukovych who had been in the village had been from Donetsk, she thought they'd been miners. Two said they'd been paid 1,500 and 2,000 griven to come and be observers.

When these observers got to the village, instead of the resistance they were expecting to find from "insular" L'vivians, they were welcomed just like any village in Ukraine might welcome distinguished guests. (that is to say, with overwhelming, occasionally pushy, generosity) They sat down with the village to a huge feast.

One of the observers, however, didn't eat. Instead he shoved all the food he got into a bag, and told the people there, "I'm going to take every bit of this home to my kids and tell them that the L'vivians are just like us."

Let's hope.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (5)

That was a great story, Dan... indeed, lets hope... and pray.

Fear is an ugly thing. It is a deliberately created emotion, in the case of eastern Ukraine. The propaganda, the campaign of fear, rains on them daily - and hides truth, to benefit evil.

Without knowledge, truth is easy to hide. What's that biblical phrase about knowledge??

If the veil of lies is lifted, I think it may well cause another kind of revolution - this one in the East and South of Ukraine. There's a good chance that just may happen - if Yushchenko follows through with his plan to concentrate much of his earliest efforts in those dark and deluded places.

I'm looking forward to the possibilities. They could be huge.

December 19, 2004 | Unregistered CommenterRon C
"All of them know that the country is rank with corruption, and this is the reason that Ukraine's potential is being squandered."

Look what happened in Romania this week. Sound familiar?

http://netwmd.com/articles/article828.html
December 19, 2004 | Unregistered CommenterTheDoctori
Merry Christmas! - Dan and Lesya
December 20, 2004 | Unregistered CommenterRon C
Dan, I love the way you write because you really get it. And I love that you don't demonize the people in the East or the Yanukovych supporters. I am curious to how they would have reacted to a vehicle covered in both orange and blue and white flags.

You worked really hard to try to understand them - their views, thoughts and beliefs. They, same as the people in the West, want the same things - a better life for themselves and their kids. Though I disagree in one part - that for people in Eastern Ukraine - it does symbolize an Est/West thing. Some of them feel, based on teaching and ethnicity, that Russia will make Ukraine strong and that Yuschenko represents a threat to having strong ties and relations with Russia. This they feel is a dangerous course of action as it will severely damage relations between the two countries. And then who is to be relied on? Not Russia, and certainly not the West. Of course, the notion of Ukraine being a strong country and economy in its own right rather than 'relying' on anyone is way too out there, for some people. This is exactly why I really like Yuschenko as a candidate and President. Because he keeps emphaszing how Ukraine can be strong, should be strong, etc. It is a pretty big paradigm shift for people who really believe that "the fall of Communism was the start of inexorable decline." I'll never forget how one person said that although people became physically free at the end of the Soviet system, mentally they remain bound.
December 21, 2004 | Unregistered CommenterHello
Hi Hello! Hello everyone! Thanks for the encouragement.

Your comment, Hello, reminds me of why I like blogging so much. You caught me. I probably did overplay my hand on the "there is no different between West and East" line. I wanted to underline the basic similarities between people in both areas of Ukraine, but I ended up sounding just a little too bit like a Yushchenko speech.

There are differences. Your concise comments cover some of them. And the people themselves often concieve of this as an East-West thing.

But those same undercurrents of reliance on Russia can be found in the West. Even my wife, who cheerfully prefers speaking Ukrainian and is not at all defeatest about Ukraine can sometimes slip, if we start talking about events over fifteen years ago.

When, for example, we watch one of the good old Soviet films, she'll talk about it as "ours" and the Soviet military was "us" and the Soviet writers, like Bulgakov, were ours, even though their national allegience would be tough to nail down.

Especially in times when Ukraine gets little attention, as will happen shortly after this election, and as happened in the ten years leading up to it, there is always the temptation to identify with a greater Soviet national identity, not as subservience to Russia, I don't think, as much as identifying with something great and big and important, something people paid attention to.

You are absolutely right that it is going to be a BIG paradigm shift to move away from that to Ukrainian national identity. It will require the development of a post-Soviet body of good literature and reconstruction of national heritage and lots of other things before the majority of Ukrainians will comfortably settle into the physical freedom of the post-Soviet era.
December 23, 2004 | Registered CommenterDan McMinn

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.